HomeExplore
Genres
Strategy GameCard GameCooperative GameSee more
Themes
FantasyFightingScience FictionSee more
Mechanics
Hand ManagementVariable Player PowersDice RollingSee more
Quick access
Short Games (< 30 min)2 Players GamesLight Playstyle Games
pay the ONE
Strategy GamesFamily GamesCard GamesWar GamesMiniature Games
  1. pay the ONEHome

Loading...

 
 

Loading...

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Paytheone
Board games made easy
Company
  • About us
  • Career
  • Contact us
Legal
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Refund Policy
© 2025 Pay the ONE™. All Rights Reserved.
Facebook: PaytheOneInstagram: PaytheOneBGTwitter: @PaytheOneBG
  1. pay the ONEHome
  2. Strategy Game
  3. WizKids
  4. Who Should We Eat?

Who Should We Eat?

A mysterious accident causes your plane to crash onto an uncharted island...and then you resort to cannibalism way too fast.

Who Should We Eat? is a lighthearted social game about... (read more)
Select an option above or just click "Explore Next" to skip this item and see the next product in your exploration list
Who Should We Eat? is not currently available from any of our partners. Add it to your wishlist to be the first notified when it is.
Check out the purchase option here
Reviews
mixed, 58% of all reviews are favorable
Playtime
30 minutes
Published
2017
Age
14+
Publisher
WizKids
Players
4 to 10 players
Designers
Mike Harrison-Wood and Chris MacLennan
Playstyle
Involved
Game's Categories
Strategy Game, Party Game, Hand Management, Cannibals / Cannibalism, Voting, WizKids (I), and Semi-Cooperative Game
Who Should We Eat? preview imageWho Should We Eat?
Check out the purchase option here

Description

A mysterious accident causes your plane to crash onto an uncharted island...and then you resort to cannibalism way too fast.

Who Should We Eat? is a lighthearted social game about plane crash survivors trying to get off an island. The only way off is to build a raft. Players play cards to gather resources for the group – adding food, sanity, and wood for the raft. Unfortunately, food is scarce and people are edible. Trials will be held to choose the survivor to sacrifice his or her life - or sometimes a knife fight will determine the person being eaten. For the survivors, this means a loss of sanity, but it also means their raft need not be as large!

However, those that are eaten, come back as ghosts and exact revenge upon the survivors trying to keep them on the island before their sanity runs out or no one is left to build the raft.

Can the team of survivors get off the island before the team of ghosts stop them?

Purchase option

Buy Who Should We Eat?
from Noble Knight Games logoNoble Knight Games

Out of Stock
Disclosure: This site includes affiliate links. PaytheOne may earn a commission for purchases made through these links, at no extra cost to you. Your support is appreciated.

Price History

Loading chart...

Game's Categories

Genres

  • Strategy Game
  • Party Game
  • Semi-Cooperative Game

Theme

  • Cannibals / Cannibalism

Mechanics

  • Variable Player Powers
  • Hand Management
  • Voting
  • Simultaneous Action Selection

Publishers

  • Broadway Toys LTD
  • WizKids
  • WizKids (I)
  • Pavana Games

Designers

  • Mike Harrison-Wood
  • Chris MacLennan

Artists

  • Pablo Hidalgo
  • Simeon Cogswell

Strategy Game

In Library
Wishlisted
Donner Dinner Party
$12.00
In Library
Wishlisted
Dice Realms
-28%
$119.95
$85.99
In Library
Wishlisted
Juicy Fruits - Mystic Island
$17.95
In Library
Wishlisted
Exit: The Stormy Flight
-31%
$15.95
$10.99
In Library
Wishlisted
Gold Raiders
$9.00
In Library
Wishlisted
Dragon Island
-76%
$36.95
$9.00
In Library
Wishlisted
The Pursuit of Happiness: Experiences
-26%
$34.95
$25.99
In Library
Wishlisted
Fireball Island - Maker Kit
$42.95
In Library
Wishlisted
Robinson Crusoe - Adventures on the Cursed Island (4th Edition)
$45.00
$44.00
In Library
Wishlisted
The Plum Island Horror
-24%
$95.00
$71.99
In Library
Wishlisted
The Plum Island Horror
-26%
$96.95
$71.99

Family Game

In Library
Wishlisted
They say no man is an island. We live within communities where we get to interact with other people, engage in various activities, have new experiences and be part of something bigger. The people around us shape who we are and in turn, we shape their...
The Pursuit of Happiness: Community Expansion
-23%
$34.99
$26.99
In Library
Wishlisted
When we arrived at the Island of Monster Masks, we were welcomed by strange creatures who laughed whenever they saw us. We have begun to fit in by wearing big masks ourselves, but we can no longer recognize one another among the inhabitants of this ...
Quickpick - Island of Monster Masks
$5.00

Elapsed Real Time Ending

In Library
Wishlisted

Unlock! - The Island of Doctor Goorse

$18.99
You and your team have crash-landed on the island of an eccentric antiques collector in Unlock! The Island of Doctor Goorse. Two to six players will be split into teams, separated in the crash, and forced to escape from two separate starting points....
mixed, 57%
10 y/o +
2 to 6 players
60 minutes
Involved
Card Game
Puzzle
Escape Room
Elapsed Real Time Ending
Storytelling
Companion App/Site

Brotherwise Games

In Library
Wishlisted

Boss Monster: Crash Landing Expansion

-25%
$11.95
$8.99
An alien spaceship has crash landed in the world of Arcadia! Expand your Boss Monster game with this mini-expansion for 5-6 players. Crash Landing introduces an all new treasure type, new heroes, new Bosses, and new rooms powered by alien monsters and...
13 y/o +
2 to 6 players
30 minutes

Hand Management

In Library
Wishlisted
-45%
$10.95
$6.00
In Library
Wishlisted
$9.00
$8.95
In Library
Wishlisted
$54.95

Lautapelit.fi

In Library
Wishlisted
$24.00
After the sinking of your boat, your group of survivors finds themselves on a desert island where water and food are scarce. The only way to escape this nightmare is to build a large raft together to escape the island, Time is short, because a hurricane...
65%
10+
3 to 12
20 mins
Light
In Library
Wishlisted
-38%
$44.95
$27.99
My Island is a family-friendly, competitive legacy game, which means that your game changes and evolves over time as you play it. After arriving on a mysterious island, you build the first houses, create fields and paths through the rainforest, and advance...
73%
10+
2 to 4
30 mins
Relaxed
In Library
Wishlisted
-28%
$23.00
$16.49
You Are Being ControlledDo we really have free will? Who decides this? Are we controlled by what we hear and what we see, even while thinking we decide freely? Insider is a game that deals with these questions. While communicating to others, you have...
74%
9+
4 to 8
15 mins
Light

Flux Capacity, The

In Library
Wishlisted

Zombie Island

-50%
$10.95
$5.50
The family vacation isn't going according to plan. Your boat sprang a leak but luckily you made to the beach of a remote tropical island. While you were making repairs your family wandered off. Time to go explore the island and find them. Man, that'...
13 y/o +
1 to 4 players
30 minutes
Horror

Big Potato

In Library
Wishlisted

Mean Girls - Party Game

-12%
$15.95
$14.00
What will you write in the Burn Book? Okay, you should just know that we don’t do this a lot, so this is like a REALLY huge deal... We want to invite you to play this game we invented. Here’s how it works: You each tear out a page of the Burn Book, ...
14 y/o +
4 to 8 players
20 minutes
Party Game

Sports

In Library
Wishlisted

Famous 500 Mile Race Game

$30.00
Choose which cars you want to win and watch as the spinner shows you who's in the lead and who's headed for a crash. The first car past the finish line wins!
8 y/o +
1 to 12 players
30 minutes
Sports

Evan's Games

In Library
Wishlisted

Big Pig Game, The

$37.95
Your family has left for the day, so it's time to eat all of the food in the house before they get back! Pick one of the cute critters to play as and work together to eat all of the food!The Big Pig Game is a cooperative food eating game for 1-4 piggies...
10 y/o +
1 to 4 players
40 minutes
Humor

Abstract Game

In Library
Wishlisted

Isle of Cats, The: Race to the Raft

-25%
$39.95
$30.00
Race to the Raft is a cooperative path building and tile laying social puzzle board game for 1 – 4 players.In the game, you play the role of the disorientated island cats who are lost on the smoke-filled island. Nothing seems to be where it once was...
12 y/o +
1 to 4 players
40 minutes
Abstract Game