HomeExplore
Genres
Strategy GameCard GameCooperative GameSee more
Themes
FantasyFightingScience FictionSee more
Mechanics
Hand ManagementVariable Player PowersDice RollingSee more
Quick access
Short Games (< 30 min)2 Players GamesLight Playstyle Games
pay the ONE
Strategy GamesFamily GamesCard GamesWar GamesMiniature Games
  1. pay the ONEHome

Loading...

 
 

Loading...

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Paytheone
Board games made easy
Company
  • About us
  • Career
  • Contact us
Legal
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Refund Policy
© 2025 Pay the ONE™. All Rights Reserved.
Facebook: PaytheOneInstagram: PaytheOneBGTwitter: @PaytheOneBG
  1. pay the ONEHome
  2. Team-Based Game
  3. Fantasy Flight Games
  4. Unfathomable

Unfathomable

Horror on the High Seas

The steamship Atlantica makes way to Boston, but dark shadows trail the ship, staying just out of sight beneath the waves. Your fellow passengers seem... (read more)

Select an option above or just click "Explore Next" to skip this item and see the next product in your exploration list
Buy our best deal
from Miniature Market logoMiniature Market
$89.99
USD 71.99
Disclosure: This site includes affiliate links. PaytheOne may earn a commission for purchases made through these links, at no extra cost to you. Your support is appreciated.
Check out all purchase options here
Reviews
mostly positive, 71% of all reviews are favorable
Playtime
120 minutes
Published
2021
Age
14+
Publisher
Fantasy Flight Games
Players
3 to 6 players
Designers
Tony Fanchi and Corey Konieczka
Playstyle
Involved
Game's Categories
Horror, Fantasy Flight Games, Novel-based, Variable Player Powers, Cthulhu, Hobby World, and Fantasy
Unfathomable preview imageUnfathomable
-20%
$89.99
$71.99
Miniature Market logo

Description

Horror on the High Seas

The steamship Atlantica makes way to Boston, but dark shadows trail the ship, staying just out of sight beneath the waves. Your fellow passengers seem unnaturally fixated, staring out to sea with a silent, desperate longing. Your dreams are plagued by eerie underwater nightmares. And now, a passenger has been murdered.

Suspicion, hidden loyalties, and devious strategy rule the day! Unfathomable puts you and your friends in command of a steamship, but not all of you can be trusted. While monstrous Deep Ones stream forth from the crushing ocean depths, any player could secretly be a nefarious cultist of a horrifying hybrid Deep One. Don't turn your back on anyone - it will take all your cunning to save your ship from a watery grave.

Battle swarming Deep Ones, uncover the traitors, and steer the Atlantica safely home in Unfathomable!

Mechanisms:

1 Learn to Play1 Rules Reference1 Game Board22 Plastic Monster Figures10 Character Sheets3 Traitor Reference Sheets6 Player Reference Sheets10 Character Standees1 Current Player Token4 Traitor Rings9 Passenger Tokens1 Eight-sided Die1 Travel Token1 Ritual Token14 Loyalty Cards70 Mythos Cards2 Title Cards20 Spell Cards20 Waypoint Cards20 Item Cards9 Ship Damage Cards10 Feat Cards126 Skill Cards

Contents

  • 1 Learn to Play
  • 1 Rules Reference
  • 1 Game Board
  • 22 Plastic Monster Figures
  • 10 Character Sheets
  • 3 Traitor Reference Sheets
  • 6 Player Reference Sheets
  • 10 Character Standees
  • 1 Current Player Token
  • 4 Traitor Rings
  • 9 Passenger Tokens
  • 1 Eight-sided Die
  • 1 Travel Token
  • 1 Ritual Token
  • 14 Loyalty Cards
  • 70 Mythos Cards
  • 2 Title Cards
  • 20 Spell Cards
  • 20 Waypoint Cards
  • 20 Item Cards
  • 9 Ship Damage Cards
  • 10 Feat Cards
  • 126 Skill Cards

Purchase options

Buy Unfathomable
from Miniature Market logoMiniature Market

$89.99
USD 71.99

Buy Unfathomable
from Noble Knight Games logoNoble Knight Games

USD 74.95
Disclosure: This site includes affiliate links. PaytheOne may earn a commission for purchases made through these links, at no extra cost to you. Your support is appreciated.

Price History

Loading chart...

Game's Categories

Genre

  • Team-Based Game

Themes

  • Fantasy
  • Miniatures
  • Novel-based
  • Horror
  • Cthulhu
  • Art

Mechanics

  • Variable Player Powers
  • Hand Management
  • Bluffing
  • Deduction
  • Area Movement
  • Traitor Game
  • Hidden Roles

Publishers

  • ADC Blackfire Entertainment
  • Galápagos Jogos
  • Hobby World
  • Rebel Sp. z o.o.
  • Delta Vision Publishing
  • Geekach Games
  • Fantasy Flight Games
  • GoKids 玩樂小子
  • Geekach LLC

Designers

  • Tony Fanchi
  • Corey Konieczka

Artists

  • Henning Ludvigsen
  • Adam Baker

Miniatures

In Library
Wishlisted
Arkham Horror - Arkham Horror Files: Unfathomable - From the Abyss
In Library
Wishlisted
Skull Tales - Full Sail!
In Library
Wishlisted
Cthulhu: Death May Die - Season 2 Expansion
In Library
Wishlisted
Arkham Horror: Witch
In Library
Wishlisted
Arkham Horror: Colour Out of Space
In Library
Wishlisted
Arkham Horror: Hunting Horror
In Library
Wishlisted
Arkham Horror: Haunter of the Dark
In Library
Wishlisted
Arkham Horror: High Priest

Fantasy Flight Games

In Library
Wishlisted
-34%
$64.99
$42.99
Terror from the Depths!The decrepit village of Innsmouth creaks under the weight of growing corruption. The mist-shrouded streets of seaside Kingsport hide ancient mysteries. The tide is rising...Under Dark Waves brings your investigation to Innsmouth...
88%
14+
1 to 6
120 mins
Involved
In Library
Wishlisted
-20%
$69.99
$55.99
"I cannot think of the deep sea without shuddering at the nameless things that may at this very moment be crawling and floundering on its slimy bed . . ." -H.P. LovecraftThis voyage just got a lot more dangerous.In From the Abyss, the SS Atlantica and...
14+
3 to 6
120 to 240 mins
In Library
Wishlisted
-18%
$16.99
$13.99
A Thousand Shapes of Horror is the second Mythos Pack in The Dream-Eaters cycle. It contains Scenario II-B and cards 155-194.After half of your team has seemingly become trapped in the Dreamlands, you decide to force your way into the realm in your physical...
85%
14+
1 to 2
60 to 120 mins
Involved

Strategy Game

In Library
Wishlisted

Monopoly: Boston in a Box

$15.95
Boston themed monopoly style board game.
8 y/o +
2 to 6 players
60 minutes
Family Game

Action Points

In Library
Wishlisted
Throughout your Innsmouth investigations, you have ventured into tide-hollowed caves and dripping tunnels—but these watery caverns are only the antechamber of the Deep Ones’ domain. A hidden city rests beneath the choppy waves of the North Atlantic,...
Arkham Horror: The Card Game - Into the Maelstrom: Mythos Pack
$17.95
$16.99
In Library
Wishlisted
The Depths of Yoth is the fifth Mythos Pack in The Forgotten Age cycle.Following the events of The City of Archives, your team of investigators find yourselves trapped deep in the of the Earth and the only way out is...down. Your mission to protect humanity...
Arkham Horror LCG: The Depths of Yoth Mythos Pack
-30%
$19.95
$13.99

Travel

In Library
Wishlisted
Across the globe, ancient evil is stirring. Now, you and your trusted circle of colleagues must travel around the world, working against all odds to hold back the approaching horror. Foul monsters, brutal encounters, and obscure mysteries will take ...
Arkham Horror - Arkham Horror Files: Eldritch Horror
$63.95
$58.00
In Library
Wishlisted
Forsaken Lore is the first expansion for Eldritch Horror, immersing you and your investigators more fully into the global fight for the survival of humankind. As the ancient ones grow in power, investigators must work harder than ever to save our world...
Arkham Horror - Arkham Horror Files: Eldritch Horror - Forsaken Lore Expansion
$23.95
$22.00

USAOpoly

In Library
Wishlisted

Monopoly - Historic Boston Edition

$0.00
Monopoly, the world’s most popular board game, with a Historic Boston theme
8 y/o +
2 to 10 players
100 minutes

Card Game

In Library
Wishlisted
Whereas The House on the Hill surrounds you with the trappings of a horror story, The Nautilus’ Traps brings you to the bottom of the sea. When a sea monster attacks your submarine at the outset of the adventure, it’s up to you to make your way through...
Unlock! - The Nautilus' Traps
-63%
$13.49
$5.00
In Library
Wishlisted
Your art gallery is expanding! As the curator, you have find taste in art, but for the gallery to succeed you'll need to pay close attention to what your visitors want to see.Build out your art gallery with new exhibits, based on the categories your ...
ArtSee
-67%
$30.00
$10.00

Heidelberger Spieleverlag

In Library
Wishlisted
$325.00
Miskatonic University is a place of learning and discovery. However, the diligent researchers of the acclaimed college are about to uncover a host of terrible mysteries that should have remained buried... Build upon your Arkham Horror experience with...
78%
12+
1 to 8
120 mins
Involved
In Library
Wishlisted
-24%
$44.95
$34.00
Explore the farthest reaches of Antarctica in Mountains of Madness, the second expansion for Eldritch Horror. Inspired by H.P. Lovecraft's novella about an Antarctic expedition ravaged by inhuman, prehistoric creatures, this expansion allows you to ...
84%
14+
1 to 8
120 mins
Involved
In Library
Wishlisted
$249.95
$230.00
The Ancient Ones plaguing Arkham and Dunwich have set their sights on yet another pastoral Massachusetts community, but this town has some ancient and powerful forces watching over it.
70%
12+
1 to 8
120 mins
Involved
In Library
Wishlisted
$15.00
From the streets of Paris to the city's subterranean catacombs, your pursuit of the truth behind The King in Yellow leads you farther and farther from Arkham's familiar landmarks. But the streets, the language, and the eerie, dark tunnels aren't the...
89%
14+
1 to 4
60 to 120 mins
Involved

Campaign Game

In Library
Wishlisted
-18%
$21.99
$17.99
In Library
Wishlisted
-18%
$21.99
$17.99
In Library
Wishlisted
-18%
$32.99
$26.99

Late for the Sky

In Library
Wishlisted

Boston-Opoly (City)

$17.95
Boston is one of those cities. Its range and depth of history are unequaled, but Boston has a youthful spirit. Skyscrapers of tomorrow stand respectfully alongside cherished symbols of yesterday. Built by people from every corner of the world, great...
8 y/o +
2 to 6 players
60 minutes

Elf Creek Games

In Library
Wishlisted

End of the Trail

-35%
$18.49
$12.00
1849, the California Gold Rush.Do you have what it takes to find your fortune in gold? Search the land, press your luck, pitch your tents, and play your cards right to find out.End of the Trail is a strategy card and tile game for 1-4 players that plays...
10 y/o +
1 to 4 players
20 minutes

Maldito Games

In Library
Wishlisted

The Stifling Dark

-49%
$95.00
$47.99
The Stifling Dark is a one-vs-many hidden-movement horror board game with an innovative line-of-sight mechanic for 2-5 players.One player assumes the role of the Adversary, whose goal is to prevent the other players (the investigators) from escaping....
mostly positive, 71%
14 y/o +
2 to 5 players
25 minutes
Involved
Team-Based Game
Horror
Movies / TV / Radio theme
Deduction
Hidden Movement
Line of Sight
Memory