HomeExplore
Genres
Strategy GameCard GameCooperative GameSee more
Themes
FantasyFightingScience FictionSee more
Mechanics
Hand ManagementVariable Player PowersDice RollingSee more
Quick access
Short Games (< 30 min)2 Players GamesLight Playstyle Games
pay the ONE
Strategy GamesFamily GamesCard GamesWar GamesMiniature Games
  1. pay the ONEHome

Loading...

 
 

Loading...

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Paytheone
Board games made easy
Company
  • About us
  • Career
  • Contact us
Legal
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Refund Policy
© 2026 Pay the ONE™. All Rights Reserved.
Facebook: PaytheOneInstagram: PaytheOneBGTwitter: @PaytheOneBG
  1. pay the ONEHome
  2. Card Game
  3. Victory Point Games
  4. I Say, Holmes! (2nd Edition)

I Say, Holmes! (2nd Edition)

"Come, Watson, come!" he cried. "The game is afoot."
- Sherlock Holmes, The Adventure of The Abbey Grange

Don your deerstalker hat and cape for I Say, Holmes!, a card-driven... (read more)
Select an option above or just click "Explore Next" to skip this item and see the next product in your exploration list
I Say, Holmes! (2nd Edition) is not currently available from any of our partners. Add it to your wishlist to be the first notified when it is.
Check out the purchase option here
Playtime
30 minutes
Published
2014
Age
13+
Publisher
Victory Point Games
Players
3 to 8 players
Designer
Playstyle
Involved
Game's Categories
Strategy Game and Card Game
I Say, Holmes! (2nd Edition) preview imageI Say, Holmes! (2nd Edition)
Check out the purchase option here

Description

"Come, Watson, come!" he cried. "The game is afoot."
- Sherlock Holmes, The Adventure of The Abbey Grange

Don your deerstalker hat and cape for I Say, Holmes!, a card-driven romp through Victorian England that has you trying to come out on top of a Sherlock Holmes investigation. Some rounds you'll be playing the Great Detective himself as you attempt to arrest the villains, while other times you will be one of the criminals (from Colonel Moran to Professor Moriarty) trying to escape Holmes' grasp.

The first edition of I Say, Holmes! was named one of Toys Bulletin's Best of 2013, and this new version features completely new art alongside custom-shaped, laser-cut counters.

What's In The Box?:

  • One 20-page, full-color Rules booklet
  • 125 color, die-cut cards
  • 36 thick, laser-cut, multi-shaped counter pieces (minor assembly required)
  • One bright red, 9 1/4" x 5 7/8" Standard cardboard VPG game box
  • One beautiful box cover sleeve
  • One "Wipes-A-Lot" napkin
  • One charcoal desiccant packet
  • Purchase option

    Buy I Say, Holmes! (2nd Edition)
    from Noble Knight Games logoNoble Knight Games

    Out of Stock
    Disclosure: This site includes affiliate links. PaytheOne may earn a commission for purchases made through these links, at no extra cost to you. Your support is appreciated.

    Price History

    Loading chart...

    Game's Categories

    Genres

    • Card Game
    • Strategy Game

    Publisher

    • Victory Point Games

    Space Cowboys

    In Library
    Wishlisted
    Sherlock Holmes - Watson & Holmes
    $35.00
    $32.00
    In Library
    Wishlisted
    Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: Baker Street Irregulars
    -20%
    $59.99
    $47.99
    In Library
    Wishlisted
    Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: Jack the Ripper & West End Adventures
    -20%
    $59.99
    $47.99
    In Library
    Wishlisted
    Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: Carlton House & Queen's Park
    -19%
    $57.99
    $46.99

    Broadway Toys LTD

    In Library
    Wishlisted
    -28%
    $17.95
    $12.99
    Sherlock Holmes needs your help! The famous journalist Ignatius Loyde was murdered shortly after an article he published portrayed Sherlock Holmes as an imposter. There are leads that make Holmes the prime suspect in the murder - and Holmes has disappeared...
    65%
    12+
    1 to 4
    60 mins
    Relaxed
    In Library
    Wishlisted
    $15.95
    In Sherlock 13, first published as Holmes 13, the players take the role of a detective, trying to unmask the famous thief Arsene Lupin, who is among them in disguise.The game consists of 13 character cards, with 2 to 3 characteristics each. Each characteristi...
    61%
    10+
    2 to 4
    15 mins
    Light
    In Library
    Wishlisted
    -20%
    $44.99
    $35.99
    No Lack of Little Mysteries on Baker Street!Not even Sherlock Holmes, the greatest detective, could predict these mysteries. . .Fortunately, the animals are on the case! Whether you're feathered or furry, play as the best investigators on the street ...
    78%
    10+
    1 to 4
    45 mins
    Relaxed

    Novel-based

    In Library
    Wishlisted
    Scotland Yard: Sherlock Holmes Edition
    In Library
    Wishlisted
    Sherlock Solitaire
    In Library
    Wishlisted
    Holmes - Sherlock & Mycroft
    In Library
    Wishlisted
    Beyond Baker Street
    In Library
    Wishlisted
    Monsters vs. Heroes - Vol. 1, Victorian Nightmares
    In Library
    Wishlisted
    Sherlock Express
    In Library
    Wishlisted
    Lady Alice

    Strategy Game

    In Library
    Wishlisted
    Picture Perfect - The Sherlock Expansion
    $19.95
    In Library
    Wishlisted
    Sherlock 13 (English/Korean Edition)
    $15.95
    In Library
    Wishlisted
    Chamber of Wonders: Sherlock - A Chamber in Red Expansion
    -25%
    $19.95
    $15.00
    In Library
    Wishlisted
    Decktective: Lock Up Sherlock Holmes!
    $12.95
    In Library
    Wishlisted
    World of Smog, The: Baker Street Set, The
    -33%
    $29.95
    $20.00

    Murder / Mystery

    In Library
    Wishlisted
    Ten fully revised cases for the Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective line from Space Cowboys will soon be available with the newest standalone box, The Thames Murders and Other Cases. Like the previously released Jack the Ripper & West End Adventures...
    Sherlock Holmes - Consulting Detective, The Thames Murders and Other Cases
    $50.00
    $48.00
    In Library
    Wishlisted
    Enola Holmes is an all-against-one cooperative family game where the detectives travel around London solving puzzles to gain the clues that will fuel their deductions.One player is the Criminal, hatching a sinister plan to abduct their victim, leaving...
    Enola Holmes
    $36.95

    Ares Games

    In Library
    Wishlisted

    Monsters vs. Heroes: Vol 1 Victorian Nightmares

    -46%
    $14.90
    $8.00
    Fighting to the Death in the Streets of Victorian England!Meet Van Helsing and Sherlock Holmes, Vampires and Imps, Queen Victoria and the Baker Street Irregulars, in this thrilling mash-up of Victorian mystery and horror stories.At the start of the game...
    8 y/o +
    2 to 8 players
    10 to 30 minutes

    Contracts

    In Library
    Wishlisted

    Victorian Masterminds

    -70%
    $49.99
    $15.00
    Massive machines of enormous military capabilities have been reported in the remote corners of the world. Mister Sherlock Holmes remains unaccounted for and Scotland Yard reports no leads in the ongoing investigation. Truly, the world is fruit ripe for...
    mixed, 65%
    14 y/o +
    2 to 4 players
    50 minutes
    Relaxed
    Strategy Game
    Miniatures
    Steampunk
    Contracts
    Sudden Death Ending
    Variable Player Powers
    Worker Placement

    Indie Boards & Cards

    In Library
    Wishlisted
    -20%
    $29.99
    $23.99
    A crime most heinous has been committed in foggy London. The greatest minds in the city race to identify the criminal. The first to solve the case will earn eternal notoriety as London's greatest deductive genius. The game is afoot!Sherlock: The Game...
    59%
    14+
    2 to 5
    45 mins
    Relaxed
    In Library
    Wishlisted
    -23%
    $21.95
    $17.00
    The Game is Afoot!The Sherlock Files: Marvelous Mysteries includes three new confounding cases to solve.Investigate the mysterious death of a Victorian lawyer. Has his spirit returned to accuse his murderer?Follow the trail of a famous masterpiece that...
    14+
    1 to 8
    60 mins
    In Library
    Wishlisted
    $4.95
    $4.50
    The Sherlock Files is a cooperative mystery series. This demo deck is a quick introduction to the system that you can play with 1-8 players in 30 minutes.
    14+
    1 to 8
    30 mins
    In Library
    Wishlisted
    $21.95
    THE GAME IS AFOOT!The Sherlock Files: Curious Capers includes three new confounding cases to solve.Investigate the family, friends, and business partners of a freshly deceased don.Uncover how a group of devious jewel thieves and their loot vanished ...
    14+
    1 to 8
    60 mins

    Lucky Duck Games

    In Library
    Wishlisted

    Sherlock - Case Connection

    -36%
    $21.95
    $14.00
    Face Sherlock’s greatest adversaries!Sherlock: Case Connection is a competitive puzzle game of plots and deduction!1. Visit locations to gather evidence.2. Use your evidence to connect threads.3. Connect multiple threads to Sherlock’s foes to score ...
    8 y/o +
    2 to 4 players
    30 minutes
    Family Game

    Puzzle

    In Library
    Wishlisted

    Case of the Secret Society, The

    $0.00
    A Sherlock Holmes inspired wooden puzzle from Professor Puzzle.The Society of Shadows is a clandestine brotherhood seeking to exploit their ancestors’ connections and establish themselves as London’s criminal overlords. To infiltrate the society and...
    0 y/o +
    0 players
    Unknown
    Puzzle

    Collectible Card Game

    In Library
    Wishlisted

    Uprising Booster Pack - Velden's Wrath

    $3.95
    The mighty Velden has come from the far north. Has this wrathful titan come to fight the forces of Drakka and demons of Raxxa, or is he just another one of the mysterious Helion's puppets? The fairies say he is the one heralded by the mist guides, and...
    0 y/o +
    0 players
    Unknown
    Card Game
    Fantasy
    Collectible Card Game
    Collectible Components